| | | | | | | | | | BUC | CLO | DER | DUR | ESS | GLA | GLO | HAM | KEN | LAN | LAR | LEI | | LIM | LUR | MID | NOR | NOT | PEM | SOM | SUR | SUS | WAR | WOR | YOR | | Team Index | Draft History | Starters: Positional - Pitchers | Registers: Batters - Pitchers | Leaders: Batters - Pitchers |  | Middlesex Crusaders Pitching Staff Chart |
| | Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1920 74-88 | STARFFIN 15-13, 4.74 | Day 8-12, 4.00 | Knowlson 7-19, 5.58 | Frankhouse 12-10, 3.28 | McMurtry 4-5, 3.87 | Schmutz 21 SV, 3.50 | Rodney 72 G, 5.01 | Tobik 55 G, 4.10 | Schmutz 54 G, 3.50 | | 1921 71-91 | Day 12-18, 4.66 | McMurtry 9-15, 3.89 | STARFFIN 17-10, 4.24 | Seo 6-13, 3.56 | Frankhouse 6-15, 5.14 | Rodney 24 SV, 2.88 | Tobik 80 G, 4.72 | Schmutz 61 G, 3.99 | Tabaka 58 G, 2.98 | | 1922 62-100 | McMurtry 1-9, 4.51 | Seo 7-14, 3.92 | Day 4-14, 4.72 | STARFFIN 8-10, 3.80 | Frankhouse 0-6, 4.57 | Rodney 14 SV, 3.79 | Taylor 66 G, 4.55 | Rodney 61 G, 3.79 | Schmutz 57 G, 2.06 | | 1923 80-82 | PARAGO 13-16, 3.96 | Howell 19-9, 3.29 | Singer 9-17, 4.08 | Splittorff 14-14, 3.14 | STARFFIN 10-8, 3.96 | Wilson 26 SV, 2.45 | Wilson 51 G, 2.45 | Rodney 44 G, 2.67 | PARAGO 36 G, 3.96 | | 1924 62-98 | PARAGO 9-19, 4.14 | Singer 7-17, 3.85 | Splittorff 8-18, 3.68 | STARFFIN 13-11, 3.98 | Howell 6-14, 4.59 | Wilson 27 SV, 2.08 | Day 46 G, 5.28 | Tobik 46 G, 3.86 | Wilson 45 G, 2.08 | | | Top 5 pitchers in Games Started, Top pitcher in Saves and Top 3 pitchers in Games | |